Skip to main content

Anonymous (not verified)

February 21, 2020

Its good that his family have such wonderful memories of him. Sad that his daughters are growing up without their daddy

Posted by eleanordahlstrom

Anonymous (not verified)

February 21, 2020

For hope and inspiration check out my facebook page: 9/11 "Whispers from Heaven"

God Bless.

Posted by Stacy

Henry Marks (not verified)

July 12, 2023

I was 6 years old when this day occurred and I remember this day vividly. Such horror and severe loss. Rest in peace to all of whom passed that day and I wish peace and happiness to all family members.

Posted by Henry Marks

Brett (not verified)

December 06, 2023

Jim is an amazing man. Your memory will live on.  You demonstrated so much courage on ABC7.  We will never, ever forget you and how strong you were. 

Posted by Brett

Add new Guest Book entry

Restricted HTML

  • You can align images (data-align="center"), but also videos, blockquotes, and so on.
  • You can caption images (data-caption="Text"), but also videos, blockquotes, and so on.

Guestbook comments are held until moderator approval.

In addition to this Guestbook post, if you are a family or friend of this victim, we welcome you to contribute photographs, documents, or stories to this Living Memorial page. To do so, complete this submission form . Your content will be reviewed by our team, and a staff member will reach out to you at your convenience.

Place of Residence:
New York, NY
Location on 9/11:
Studley | Commercial Real Estate Broker
The New York Times Portraits of Grief
James M. Gartenberg Scholarship Fund
Hobbies and Special Interests:
University of Michigan

When I first met him, he was running the University of Michigan Alumni Club meeting. He was president of the New York City chapter. I was impressed with his leadership skills, how well he was organized, his intelligence, his presence, his ability to negotiate in difficult situations when there was conflict. I said to myself, `I want to marry him.' "

That was in 1989. James M. Gartenberg, a man who would be hugely thrilled to know that Coach Lloyd Carr and the entire Michigan football squad signed a condolence card to his family, took a long time to come to the same conclusion about Jill Freeberg that she had about him.

But figure it out he surely did. Married six years ago, happily ensconced on the Upper East Side, father of Nicole, 2, with another child on the way, Mr. Gartenberg, 35, was moving out of his office at 1 World Trade Center on Sept. 11. His employer, Julien J. Studley Inc., the commercial real estate firm, was shifting him to Midtown.

Mr. Gartenberg spent some of his last minutes on ABC-TV, calmly describing the situation on the 86th floor.

He was making plans to take his family to next month's Michigan-Wisconsin game. He had taught Nicole -- "his heart and soul" -- to yell "Go Blue!" when Michigan was on television. He secretly fantasized about wearing navy pants embossed with little maize M's when he was suitably old.